Pioneering architect Kamil Khan Mumtaz led a session at the Lahore Fort in which he underscored the pressing need for restoration that goes beyond heritage sites.
The talk, titled the ‘Café Learning Session’, was held at the Fort’s historic Barood Khana and organized by Aga Khan Cultural Service – Pakistan (AKCS-P). The event brought together a diverse group of creative professionals working in conservation and architecture, including architects, fine artists, conservation experts, engineers and archivists.
Discussions focused on the dangers of unchecked industrialization, namely climate change and its destructive impacts and raditional economies of earlier centuries being more conducive to sustaining the environment.
Tracing the link between humans and the environment, Mumtaz contended that life requires an interaction with the environment, which involves extracting resources from it and giving back to it. This has to be an equal exchange, he argued.
“You cannot sustain an unequal balance; in our dealings and exchange with nature there is a measurable and precise limit that cannot be exceeded.”
He warned that nature does not possess unlimited resources. “To put it simply, we cannot take more from it than its capacity. The ideal state of an ecosystem is one of perfect balance between ‘give and take’, which is essentially the normative state,” he observed.
Giving a new context to term ‘circular economy’, Mumtaz added that 300,000 years ago, the world was governed by a natural economy in which humans only took from nature what they needed and gave back what they didn’t need. This economy, he said, sustained life in perfect balance. “In a hunting-gathering society there was no advantage of hunting more. You hunt only as much as you require.”
Mumtaz critiqued the contemporary discourse on conservation, which, he maintained, echoes a postmodern view of the world that regards heritage sites primarily as material assets. Instead, he said, the deeper philosophy of conservation needs to be understood — one that looks to the wisdom of the past and offers enduring insights for the present. This wisdom is evident in traditional building techniques that were responsive to the climate and created resilient infrastructure.
Sharing his thoughts on the talk, AKCS-P CEO Tausif Khawaja said: “Today’s session made a strong case for mainstreaming traditional knowledge and techniques. The value of these approaches is evident in the traditional building practices used in historic structures that are climate-friendly and produce resilient structures. Heritage sites across our country have stood the test of time and remain majestic examples of architectural excellence.”